The development of high-fidelity full-core modeling capabilities for LWRs aims to reduce uncertainty in the design margins and to facilitate optimization of reactor operations including fuel management, power uprates, and life extensions. Successful examples for such developments include projects such as CASL (Consortium for Advanced Simulation of LWRs) and Nuclear Reactor Safety Simulation Platform (NURESAFE).
In 2019, the Working Party on Scientific Issues and Uncertainty Analysis of Reactor Systems (WPRS) launched a benchmark, in which the work performed by CASL in their VERA Core Physics Benchmark Progression Problems is extended into a Nuclear Energy Agency code-independent benchmark to encourage Verification and Validation (V&V) of traditional and novel high-fidelity Modelling and Simulation (M&S) from multiple participants.
The benchmark specifications originate from a selected set of CASL benchmark problems based on data provided by the Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) and other references available in the public domain. It introduces a benchmark which provides detailed specifications of the WB1 core operations measured by TVA. The data are provided for Watts Bar Unit 1 Cycle 1 (WB1C1), Cycle 2 (WB1C2), and Cycle 3 (WP1C3). Seven exercises cover the key states of WB1C1 to WB1C3. The exercises span the start-up Zero Power Physics Tests (ZZPT), Hot Full Power (HFP) Beginning of Cycle (BOC) Physical Reactor, depletion of WB1C1, fuel shuffle and decay for Cycle 2 BOC ZPPT, and WBN1C2 depletion, fuel shuffle and decay for WB1C3 BOC ZPPT, and WB1C3 depletion:
In 2025, the Expert Group on Physics of Reactor Systems (EGPRS) launched a follow-up benchmark to analyse reactor pressure vessel fluence simulations based on the here described TVA-WB1 multiphysics benchmark:
To participate in the benchmark and to gain access to the working area, please fill out the TVA-WB1 Conditions for Release form and e-mail it to wprs@oecd-nea.org.
Details, including specifications and results templates can be found in the working area.
TVA WB1 Benchmark (requires password | reminder)
The ANS journal Nuclear Science and Engineering (NSE) is organising a series of special issues featuring papers on the WPRS Benchmarks. These issues will serve as enduring, high-impact repositories of knowledge on their specific subjects. Expertise and experience preservation will support future research, innovation, education, and training activities for enhancing modeling and simulation capabilities for nuclear reactor design and safety analysis as well as for developing the nuclear engineering workforce.
In particular, they are currently seeking submissions related to the TVA WB1 Benchmark, either as authors or as reviewers. Please inform Kostadin Ivanov if you plan to submit a paper to the special issue or if you would like to serve as a reviewer for the special issue.